June 26, 2024 | Sarah Ng

The Real Alice: Life Wasn't A Wonderland


The Real Alice

We all know the classic children's story Alice's Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll—but few know the story of the very real little girl who inspired the beloved tale.Liddell-Msn2

She Came From A Large Family

Born in 1852, Alice Liddell was the fourth of ten children. When her father, Henry Liddell, became Dean of Christ Church in Oxford, the family moved to the new city—and an exciting chapter of Alice's life began.

Alice Liddell (1852 - 1934) that was taken by Charles Dodgson aka Lewis Carroll.Robbin Atwell, Flickr

Advertisement

She Conversed With Adults At A Young Age

Alice's parents became celebrities at Oxford, introducing their children to the glittering world of high society. She learned social graces and could carry on conversations with adults. 

Photo of Alice Liddell published - 1861Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

She Was A Proper Young Lady

The Deanery hosted receptions, parties, and soirees. It was the perfect environment for the Liddell girls to grow into proper young ladies. Alice's mother already had her eye set on the future—and wanted to ensure that her girls would one day marry well.

Little did Alice know, she had yet to meet the man destined to become a defining part of her childhood. 

Edith, Lorina & Alice Liddell - 1859Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

She Met Someone In The Garden

On April 25, 1856, Alice's life changed forever. She and her sisters Lorina and Edith had slipped away from the supervision of their governess to play in the garden. This is where she met 24-year-old Charles Dodgson (Lewis Carroll).

Portrait of Lewis Carroll - 1863Oscar Gustave Rejlander, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Couldn't Sit Still

When Alice and her sisters first ran into Charles Dodgson, he was busy taking photographs of the cathedral. They had been explicitly drawn to him out of curiosity. And when Dodgson saw them, he attempted to take their portraits. Unfortunately, the girls couldn't sit still long enough for him to capture a decent photo.

But this was only the beginning of Dodgson's curious relationship with the Liddell family.

Auto Portrait De Charles Dodgson - circa 1858Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

Her Family Welcomed Him Into Their Home

Dogdson was already friends with Alice's brother Harry when he met her. As well, Alice's father happened to share Dodgson's interest in photography. This led to the Liddell family welcoming the young man into their home.

He began taking photographs of themand their lives became fatefully intertwined.

Lewis Carroll Self Portrait - Circa 1856Reginald Southey, Wikimedia Commons

He Took Pictures Of Children

Though Charles Dodgson, or Lewis Carroll, is best known as a writer, there was a moment in time where he was just as renowned for his photographs—most notably of children.

Alice Liddell posing as a beggar - 1858Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Let Them Play Dress-Up

Dodgson set up his studio and dark room close to Tom Tower—and it became a den of youthful delights. He had a collection of costumes for his subjects to play dress-up in. But that was only the tip of the iceberg.

Lorina And Alice Liddell - 1898Stuart Dodgson Collingwood, Wikimedia Commons

He Catered To Their Interests

In Dodgson's photography studio, one could find all kinds of diversions: toys, puzzles, and so many games. The children would never grow bored in a room like this, and could keep themselves preoccupied while Dodgson prepared his equipment.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

She Was His Most Famous Muse

One of Dodgson's most famous photos of Alice is of her dressed as a beggar. However, the girls did far more with Dodgson than just pose for photos.

Photograph of Alice Liddell by Lewis Carroll - 1859/60Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Her Took Her On Outings

As time passed, the Liddell girls began spending a good amount of time with the young photographer. Chaperoned by their governess, Dodgson and the girls went on outings together. One of Alice's favorite places to visit was the University Museum.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) and Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

She Loved The Museum

The University Museum utterly captivated Alice with its fascinating dinosaur skeletons and preserved wildlife specimens. She was particularly intrigued by the extinct Dodo—a creature that you might remember from Alice's Adventures in Wonderland.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

The Importance Of The Dodo

In Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, the character of the Dodo represents Dodgson himself. Some believe that Dodgson chose the Dodo because of his stutter. He often introduced himself by stammering, "Do-do-dodgson."

Screenshot of Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Advertisement

He Was A Master Storyteller

In addition to taking the girls out on interesting outings, Dodgson also employed his storytelling prowess, weaving stories for them while on their excursions. However, there was one story that would live on forever.

Lewis Carroll image - 1898Stuart Dodgson Collingwood, Wikimedia Commons

The Beginning Of Alice in Wonderland

On July 4, 1962, Dodgson took the girls out on a boat. Floating along the Thames toward Godstow, Dodgson outdid himself when he told the story of a little girl named Alice, who falls into a rabbit hole and experiences the most fantastical adventure of her life.

Portrait of Alice Liddell - 1858Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

She Wanted Her Own Copy

Alice Liddell adored Dodgson's story so much, she asked him to give her a physical copy. The author obliged, but it took some time. He worked on the story slowly and even illustrated it. It wasn't until 1864, that he finally completed the manuscript.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Advertisement

He Dedicated It To Her

On November 26, 1864, Charles Dodgson finally granted Alice's wish, gifting her the manuscript for Alice's Adventures Under Ground. The dedication read, "A Christmas Gift to a Dear Child in Memory of a Summer's Day." 

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) and Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

The Published Version Was Different

Of course, Alice's Adventures Under Ground is much different than the Alice's Adventures in Wonderland which we know and love. For one, the published version was almost twice as long and had different illustrations by John Tenniel. Tenniel's Alice bore little resemblance to Alice Liddell, who—judging by Dodgson's photos—had a dark brown bob.

Lewis Carroll - Portrait - 1898Stuart Dodgson Collingwood, Wikimedia Commons

References To Alice

Though some have argued that Alice's Adventures in Wonderland is not about Alice Liddell, it's hard not to see the references to Alice in the books. 

Alice Liddell as St. Agnes - 1872Julia Margaret Cameron, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Used Her Birthday

To begin with, Dodgson made the date of Alice's adventure May 4, which just happened to be Alice Liddell's birthday. He also dedicated the book "to Alice Pleasance Liddell."

Alice Liddell as the Roman goddess Pomona - 1872Julia Margaret Cameron, Wikimedia Commons

Three Liddell Sisters

Secondly, there's also a part in the story where the Dormouse says, "Once upon a time there were three little sisters... and their names were Elsie, Lacie, and Tillie." Reportedly, the pronunciation of "Liddell" sounded more like "little." Therefore, the "three little sisters" could be referring to the three Liddell sisters.

However, there were also clues in the names, "Elsie," "Lacie," and "Tillie."

Liddell, Edith, Lorina & Alice, 'Open Your Mouth...' (Lewis Carroll, 07.1860)Lewis Carroll, Wikimedia Commons

What's In A Name?

"Elsie" likely refers to Lorina as the initials of her first and middle names were L.C. 

"Lacie" is an anagram of "Alice." 

"Tillie" likely refers to Edith as her nickname was "Matilda."

Alice Pleasance Liddell - 1872Julia Margaret Cameron, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

There Was Trouble In Paradise

Though Dodgson had gifted Alice with the manuscript, all was not well between the author and the Liddell family. During the summer of 1863, something had gone horribly wrong.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

There Was A Mysterious Rift

Despite the seeming closeness between the Liddells and Dodgson, they mysteriously cut ties in June 1863. Oddly enough, there are also no records to explain the cause of this sudden break-up.

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) and Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

His Diary Entries Were Missing

The Liddell family never spoke about why Dodgson faded out of their lives, while Dodgson's own diary entries from June 27 to June 29 of 1863 are missing. 

Historians, however, have their own opinions about what may have happened.

Screenshot of Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Advertisement

He May Have Wanted To Marry Her

Multiple biographers have speculated that Charles Dodgson was romantically interested in 11-year-old Alice and may have had plans to marry her. 

Screenshot of Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Age Gap Relationships

Biographer Anne Clark argued that during the Victorian era, age gap relationships weren't as unsettling as they are today—and were even commonplace. 

Screenshot of Amelia Shankley as Alice (kid) and Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Missing Diary Entries

In 1996, another piece of the puzzle emerged. Karoline Leach—a British author—discovered the very telling "Cut pages in diary" document, a note that allegedly summed up the contents of Dodgson's missing journal entries.

Screenshot of Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

Advertisement

A Revealing Note

This stand-in note for Dodgson's diary entries is said to be written by the author's niece: "L.C. learns from Mrs. Liddell that he is supposed to be using the children as a means of paying court to the governess—he is also supposed by some to be courting Ina."

Screenshot of Ian Holm as Mr. Dodgson - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

A Hidden Scandal

The "Cut pages in diary" document hints that there may have been some scandalous gossip hovering over Dodgson's relationship with Lorina Liddell. One biographer, Jenny Woolf, believed it may have been Lorina who developed a strong attachment to the author.

However, despite much speculation, it is impossible to know what the truth of the matter is.

Lorina Liddell (sister of Alice Lidell of Alice in Wonderland) - circa 1870Museum of Photographic Arts Collections, Wikimedia Commons

Alice Grew Up

Following her close relationship with Charles Dodgson, Alice Liddell grew up. She toured Europe with her sisters Lorina and Edith, and one story claims that she even caught the eye of Queen Victoria's son, Prince Leopold. 

Photo of Alice Liddell In 1870Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Settled Down

In the end, however, she did not marry a prince. At the age of 28, Alice wed a cricketer named Reginald Hargreaves. She went on to have three sons—one of whom she named Caryl. 

St Agnes (Alice Liddell) - 1872Julia Margaret Cameron, Wikimedia Commons

She Sparked Rumors

Alice's decision to name her son "Caryl" definitely pricked up some ears as "Caryl" seemed to have a connection to Dodgson's pseudonym, Lewis Carroll. But Alice set the record straight, insisting that "Caryl" had nothing to do with "Carroll."

Screenshot of Coral Browne as Alice - from Dreamchild (1985)Thorn EMI, Dreamchild (1985)

She Sold The Original Manuscript

Alice became known as Lady Hargreaves, but after her husband passed in 1926, she found herself in a financial predicament. To afford the upkeep of her house, she decided to sell Alice's Adventures Under Groundthe very first manuscript that Dodgson had gifted her.

It sold for £15,400, which would be around £1,100,000 today.

Alice Pleasance Liddell Hargreaves - 1932Rosenbach Museum & Library, Wikimedia Commons


READ MORE

The Sad Story Behind The Little Dancer

The Sad Story Behind The Little Dancer

"Little Dancer of Fourteen Years" is one of Edgar Degas's most famous works—but few know the model behind it or her dark backstory.
August 2, 2023 Sarah Ng
Space Shuttle Challenger Blasting off into Sky

The 13 Dumbest Mistakes In History

We all make silly mistakes in our everyday lives—but luckily, they rarely have any sort of impact beyond an embarrassing memory. Unfortunately, other people throughout the years haven’t been so fortunate—and their dumb mistakes end up in the history books for all to laugh at.
April 18, 2024 Samantha Henman
Mbthumb

The Medieval Era's Most Brutal Battles—By The Numbers

The Medieval Era saw some of the messiest, most brutal battles in the history of warfar.
April 25, 2024 Jamie Hayes

The Giant Hoax That Fooled America

The Cardiff Giant—believed to be a "petrified man"—has gone down in American history as one of the most bizarre archaeological hoaxes.
April 27, 2024 Sarah Ng
Mrs. Neilson and Rosecliffe Mansion

How Rich People Spent Their Money In The Gilded Age

During the Gilded Age, the rich had so much money, they didn't know what to do with it... so they spent it on the craziest extravagances imaginable.
April 30, 2024 Sarah Ng
Shakespeare Internal

Did Shakespeare Have A Ghost Writer? Exploring The Marlovian Theory

William Shakespeare is widely regarded as the greatest writer to have ever lived—but what if he didn't write all of the works that he is so famous for?
May 7, 2024 Sam T. Weltman